{
  "schema_version": 1,
  "artifact": "mbal-ai-site/index.html",
  "reviewed_on": "2026-07-11",
  "artifact_status": "CORRECTED_SOURCE_DEPLOYED",
  "status_as_of_utc": "2026-07-11T23:01:35Z",
  "metric_claim_policy": "No positive model score is displayed because these exact sales claims do not yet have the complete six-part evidence packet required by AGENTS.md.",
  "claims": [
    {
      "id": "california_sampling",
      "verdict": "WITHDRAWN",
      "public_stat": "Not route proof",
      "public_summary": "Existing evaluation ranked observations that had already been sampled. It cannot establish what an alternative California route would have found at unsampled sites.",
      "reason": "The pooled retrospective capture calculation evaluates only station-days whose outcomes are known. It does not observe the counterfactual outcomes at sites a different route would skip or add.",
      "evidence_source_ids": [
        "product_index",
        "california_triage_output",
        "california_triage_code"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "florida_red_tide",
      "verdict": "WITHDRAWN",
      "public_stat": "Not a calendar warning",
      "public_summary": "The Florida analysis steps through later observed samples, while missing weeks remain missing. It does not establish a fixed warning time or distinct new outbreaks.",
      "reason": "The code groups observed samples by week but does not create rows for unsampled weeks before shifting. Its target is a later threshold-exceeding observation, not a separately identified outbreak episode.",
      "evidence_source_ids": [
        "product_index",
        "florida_raw_observations",
        "florida_lead_output",
        "florida_loader_code",
        "shared_lead_code"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "ireland_shellfish_toxin",
      "verdict": "WITHDRAWN",
      "public_stat": "Not a fair comparison",
      "public_summary": "The Ireland scoring used earlier Irish monitoring results, and published methods were not rerun on the same records. It does not support a no-local-data or best-published-method claim.",
      "reason": "The transfer score includes Irish history features. The available literature benchmark is descriptive rather than a same-row rerun of every published method.",
      "evidence_source_ids": [
        "product_index",
        "ireland_transfer_output",
        "ireland_walkforward_output",
        "ireland_prospective_output",
        "ireland_verification_report",
        "ireland_literature_benchmark"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "sitewide_corrections": [
    {
      "id": "universal_performance",
      "removed_scope": "Claims that MBAL is proven to beat a user's current rule or works for water anywhere.",
      "replacement_scope": "The site offers a bounded test against a named simple comparison for one place, target, and time split."
    },
    {
      "id": "forecast_language",
      "removed_scope": "Claims that the current systems warn before blooms, closures, or contamination without a verified calendar lead.",
      "replacement_scope": "A future-event claim requires a real calendar gap; same-day evidence is called detection."
    },
    {
      "id": "review_coverage",
      "removed_scope": "The claim that every result receives a second skeptical review.",
      "replacement_scope": "Headline claims receive the separate skeptical review required by the claim gate."
    },
    {
      "id": "pilot_timeline",
      "removed_scope": "The unsupported promise of a clear answer in four weeks.",
      "replacement_scope": "The pilot begins with one bounded question and a pre-agreed evidence test; no duration is promised."
    },
    {
      "id": "contact_delivery_privacy",
      "removed_scope": "The form treated third-party acceptance as proven inbox delivery and gave no processor or retention notice.",
      "replacement_scope": "The page identifies FormSubmit, links its privacy and 30-day retention statements, limits requested information, and reports only acceptance for delivery."
    }
  ],
  "evidence_sources": {
    "product_index": {
      "path": "docs/MBAL_PRODUCT_INDEX.md",
      "sha256": "f50986987f477e6d4711fa6479fe862d9504cff4c757d4b07e47730cd44ac760"
    },
    "california_triage_output": {
      "path": "reports/sampling_triage/triage_eval.json",
      "sha256": "090ca60ad1b6d3d1c6b68dc9d038000515ce1082efe85d3fc5085e39c2a2b34f"
    },
    "california_triage_code": {
      "path": "research/bacteria/sampling_triage.py",
      "sha256": "342e435496df1dfdc01cf57c880cfc600fb6798624f082cdf262bd119d728f86"
    },
    "florida_raw_observations": {
      "path": "data/external_curated/habsos_karenia/habsos_karenia.parquet",
      "sha256": "8e1afb1e190be1221f87bb8fec86bc4028697cb4774758ae50159c76ebd7d692"
    },
    "florida_lead_output": {
      "path": "reports/lead_time/karenia_gulf_leadtime.json",
      "sha256": "cc2350301b4feedc1c254650dc692fcc9196d427aaa5a20cb580b4b50ce15404"
    },
    "florida_loader_code": {
      "path": "research/hab/karenia_gulf_triage_leadtime.py",
      "sha256": "b9ebda26dce227f5b8a29090ca0e23c785fb611328d6553292912b44481fd6d7"
    },
    "shared_lead_code": {
      "path": "research/hab/cyano_national_triage_leadtime.py",
      "sha256": "c059e511d59474e72a2d8002adca88c25fed78962032468fc7788aba0304bf8d"
    },
    "ireland_transfer_output": {
      "path": "reports/hab/ca_ireland_rigorous.json",
      "sha256": "b453b004c1c6093ce2e044ff2b4facc97a6108a45c93dd98834b1065fbd4a4c9"
    },
    "ireland_walkforward_output": {
      "path": "reports/hab/da_ireland_walkforward.json",
      "sha256": "4b4e15f0bd58f64c5b0b8de8f0668ace920f6fc56bbd2c8efd824d6b091402df"
    },
    "ireland_prospective_output": {
      "path": "reports/hab/da_ireland_prospective.json",
      "sha256": "429ff9709f53e868744fc241f82a4c8af9293d75d867a2d3bf807e7690067211"
    },
    "ireland_verification_report": {
      "path": "reports/hab/ireland_da_breakthrough_verification/report.md",
      "sha256": "a0d30e052debd4a160de9d4b10870afa75dfb4f033889c092929b0e749f36481"
    },
    "ireland_literature_benchmark": {
      "path": "reports/hab/ireland_da_sota.md",
      "sha256": "2ae72b10b4d89feefc9de3dd3d19fa887e57942d8f48a8b8a971798437f53bea"
    }
  }
}